A veteran Seattle police officer accused of sexually harassing an 18-year-old police Explorer and lying about it said Tuesday he thinks top-level commanders trumped up the case to retaliate for challenging them and defending female officers who had been discriminated against.
Rob Mahoney, 46, a defensive-tactics instructor at the department's training center, said that his accuser, Heather Newstrom, was flirtatious and liked to hang around after training classes to talk to officers. He didn't deny giving her a peck on the cheek after she kissed him on the cheek and hugged him goodbye while the two were in an office after class on April 7, 2008. But, he said, that's as far as it went before he got a phone call and left.
"The allegation that I kissed her on the mouth and put my tongue in her mouth is made up," Mahoney said during Tuesday's hearing before the Public Safety Civil Service Commission.
But Newstrom, now 19 and attending the United States Military Academy, testified last week that as she stood up to leave, Mahoney grabbed her and said, "Now can I have a real kiss?" She said she was shocked and she turned her head and backed away. He dropped to his chair, placed his head in his hands, and apologized, she testified. The department's Office of Professional Accountability deemed her the more credible witness. Mahoney was suspended for 30 days and transferred to a desk job in the 911 center.
He has appealed, arguing the department lacked proof of dishonesty and unfairly disciplined him. The Seattle Police Officers' Guild says it's one of three cases in which officers were fired or disciplined for dishonesty since a new "presumption of termination" policy enacted last year. The other two cases were overturned by a civilian arbitrator, raising questions about how the new standard is applied.
Chief Gil Kerlikowske said he wanted to fire Mahoney under the policy but didn't think he had enough proof to do so. A dishonesty charge on his record, however, still would likely ruin Mahoney's career because it could be used against him in court.
The three-member commission must decide whether to uphold the chief's findings of professional misconduct and dishonesty or rule in favor of the officer. While Mahoney has no record of sustained misconduct, court records show he was the focus of a domestic-violence investigation in 2006 that resulted in no charges.
Newstrom, a Holy Names graduate, said she was 15 when she joined the police Explorers, a mentorship program for teenagers interested in police work and community service. They have uniforms and meet regularly under a department adviser. She said she enjoyed police training and providing security at community events. She said she did give hugs, which other officers said seemed like behavior typical of a high school student.
She said she got to know Mahoney taking his classes and looked to him as a mentor. Their friendship started because they share an interest in philosophy. Mahoney first noticed her because she stuck out while reading Mary Wollstonecraft's "A Vindication of the Rights of Women" while at the training center, he testified.
Mahoney testified that he's thinks investigators believed her because he made enemies on the command staff. He alleged that the captain overseeing the sexual-harassment investigation, Tag Gleason, held a grudge against him over a training program that he and several officers tried to start 8 years ago. Gleason then headed the training unit.
Mahoney said he drew Kerlikowske's scorn because he wrote a use-of-force analysis in support of two officers who were disciplined for beating a man outside a Capitol Hill nightclub over a littering complaint. The officers had asked him to do so because of his expertise. The case was one of two high-profile misconduct cases that led to a public controversy in 2007 over police accountability.
He testified that he's also in hot water for sticking up for his current girlfriend, Officer Susanna Munro, who filed a discrimination complaint against the Police Department. She testified Tuesday that she was turned down for a job on the Narcotics Unit over rumors that she was having an extramarital affair with Mahoney while married to another officer. Sgt. Alvin Little, who denied her application, is the current adviser to the Explorer program. He testified to helping Newstrom file a complaint against Mahoney.
Mahoney said he was viewed with suspicion from the start of his career because he has an advanced degree. He testified that he thinks his case was treated differently from other officers who denied allegations.
"I have no faith whatsoever in the ability of the (Office of Professional Accountability) to conduct a fair hearing of an officer who is politically unpopular in the department or in the community," he said.
Mahoney joined the department in 1998 after working as a college professor. He has a doctorate in philosophy from the University of Edinburgh. A New York City native, he started studying martial arts while growing up in the Bronx because the streets were rough but he wasn't a "tough kid," he said.
Mahoney's attorney, Alex Higgins, said the case boiled down to a "tall tale" told by Newstrom. He pointed out that Mahoney had no history of sustained complaints on his record.
While Mahoney alleges department officials were searching for reasons to ruin his career, they didn't do so three years ago when Mahoney was accused of threatening to kill his ex-girlfriend and her fiance, which triggered a criminal investigation, according to court records.
SeattlePI.com obtained court records this week showing that Mahoney's ex-girlfriend, Siolo Thompson, filed for a court protection order against him in March 2006. Her then-fiance, Bart Keogh, a doctor at Harborview Medical Center, also said in a sworn statement that Mahoney made threats to kill him.
Both said Mahoney was jealous, verbally and physically abusive to Thompson, and had used his authority as a police officer to reach her at work. A judge declined to issue a permanent order, which would have required Mahoney to surrender his gun, but entered a less restrictive restraining order under a settlement between both sides, according to court records.
Mahoney and Thompson have a son together. After their separation in 2003, the court awarded custody to Mahoney with a visitation plan. In his statements from that case, Mahoney said Thompson, also a trained martial artist, was unstable and the one who threatened him, once warning that she would run away with their son to South America, where she is from, according to court documents.
Keogh also filed a complaint with Seattle police, which was investigated. King County prosecutors reviewed the allegations but didn't file charges in part because the woman later decided not to cooperate, saying she feared jeopardizing Mahoney's career, said Ian Goodhew, chief of staff in the Prosecutor's Office.
Prosecutors require proof the victim had a reasonable fear of the threat. Another issue arose with the fiance's call to police, in which he had at first phrased as a hypothetical "what-if" an officer had threatened to kill him, Goodhew said.
The Police Department also found no evidence of misconduct and the investigation was closed. No information from that case was presented during Mahoney's Civil Service Commission hearing.
"It was so baseless and far-fetched, even the City didn't bother to do anything with it," said Higgins, Mahoney's attorney, after Tuesday's hearing on the current case. "Unfortunately, with people in family situations, people are mad at each other and there are high emotions and the courts are brought in. But there was no basis for it and that was the conclusion of everyone who looked at it."
The prior case wasn't presented this week to the Civil Service Commission because no charges were filed, which raised questions of its relevance, Assistant City Attorney Paul Olsen said after Tuesday's hearing.
In her request for the protection order, Thompson said she started dating Mahoney in 1996 when she was 19 and taking a kickboxing class that he taught at the University of Portland. Mahoney was then an adjunct professor of philosophy at the school, according to court records.
Several Seattle police officers testified this week in support of Mahoney. Many described him as a top-notch training instructor and an "asset" to the department. Some of the same officers defended him in court against his ex-girlfriend's domestic-violence allegations three years ago.
Sgt. Rich O'Neill, president of the Seattle Police Officers Guild, criticized the investigation, saying the department failed to question other potential witnesses or follow up on possibly exonerating evidence. He said Mahoney got hardball questions, while Newstrom was tossed a few softballs. Typically, lying must be proved with evidence of intent, he said.
"When someone is bringing allegations this serious, that allegation should be tested," he said.
Mahoney said he's filed a claim with the city's Office of Civil Rights against the Police Department, alleging discrimination against him for defending his girlfriend.
Under questioning from Olsen, the city's attorney, Mahoney testified about a letter he sent in January to the state Department of Labor and Industries accusing Sgt. Little of defrauding the state workers compensation fund. It also accused Assistant Chief Nick Metz of covering up misconduct. The letter was sent after Mahoney was suspended, according to testimony.
Yet, Mahoney said he would like to return to his prior assignment and continue improving self-defense training for officers. The Civil Service Commission is expected to rule within 90 days.
_____________________________
http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/localnews/2009180826_spdappeal06m.html
Rob Mahoney, 46, a defensive-tactics instructor at the department's training center, said that his accuser, Heather Newstrom, was flirtatious and liked to hang around after training classes to talk to officers. He didn't deny giving her a peck on the cheek after she kissed him on the cheek and hugged him goodbye while the two were in an office after class on April 7, 2008. But, he said, that's as far as it went before he got a phone call and left.
"The allegation that I kissed her on the mouth and put my tongue in her mouth is made up," Mahoney said during Tuesday's hearing before the Public Safety Civil Service Commission.
But Newstrom, now 19 and attending the United States Military Academy, testified last week that as she stood up to leave, Mahoney grabbed her and said, "Now can I have a real kiss?" She said she was shocked and she turned her head and backed away. He dropped to his chair, placed his head in his hands, and apologized, she testified. The department's Office of Professional Accountability deemed her the more credible witness. Mahoney was suspended for 30 days and transferred to a desk job in the 911 center.
He has appealed, arguing the department lacked proof of dishonesty and unfairly disciplined him. The Seattle Police Officers' Guild says it's one of three cases in which officers were fired or disciplined for dishonesty since a new "presumption of termination" policy enacted last year. The other two cases were overturned by a civilian arbitrator, raising questions about how the new standard is applied.
Chief Gil Kerlikowske said he wanted to fire Mahoney under the policy but didn't think he had enough proof to do so. A dishonesty charge on his record, however, still would likely ruin Mahoney's career because it could be used against him in court.
The three-member commission must decide whether to uphold the chief's findings of professional misconduct and dishonesty or rule in favor of the officer. While Mahoney has no record of sustained misconduct, court records show he was the focus of a domestic-violence investigation in 2006 that resulted in no charges.
Newstrom, a Holy Names graduate, said she was 15 when she joined the police Explorers, a mentorship program for teenagers interested in police work and community service. They have uniforms and meet regularly under a department adviser. She said she enjoyed police training and providing security at community events. She said she did give hugs, which other officers said seemed like behavior typical of a high school student.
She said she got to know Mahoney taking his classes and looked to him as a mentor. Their friendship started because they share an interest in philosophy. Mahoney first noticed her because she stuck out while reading Mary Wollstonecraft's "A Vindication of the Rights of Women" while at the training center, he testified.
Mahoney testified that he's thinks investigators believed her because he made enemies on the command staff. He alleged that the captain overseeing the sexual-harassment investigation, Tag Gleason, held a grudge against him over a training program that he and several officers tried to start 8 years ago. Gleason then headed the training unit.
Mahoney said he drew Kerlikowske's scorn because he wrote a use-of-force analysis in support of two officers who were disciplined for beating a man outside a Capitol Hill nightclub over a littering complaint. The officers had asked him to do so because of his expertise. The case was one of two high-profile misconduct cases that led to a public controversy in 2007 over police accountability.
He testified that he's also in hot water for sticking up for his current girlfriend, Officer Susanna Munro, who filed a discrimination complaint against the Police Department. She testified Tuesday that she was turned down for a job on the Narcotics Unit over rumors that she was having an extramarital affair with Mahoney while married to another officer. Sgt. Alvin Little, who denied her application, is the current adviser to the Explorer program. He testified to helping Newstrom file a complaint against Mahoney.
Mahoney said he was viewed with suspicion from the start of his career because he has an advanced degree. He testified that he thinks his case was treated differently from other officers who denied allegations.
"I have no faith whatsoever in the ability of the (Office of Professional Accountability) to conduct a fair hearing of an officer who is politically unpopular in the department or in the community," he said.
Mahoney joined the department in 1998 after working as a college professor. He has a doctorate in philosophy from the University of Edinburgh. A New York City native, he started studying martial arts while growing up in the Bronx because the streets were rough but he wasn't a "tough kid," he said.
Mahoney's attorney, Alex Higgins, said the case boiled down to a "tall tale" told by Newstrom. He pointed out that Mahoney had no history of sustained complaints on his record.
While Mahoney alleges department officials were searching for reasons to ruin his career, they didn't do so three years ago when Mahoney was accused of threatening to kill his ex-girlfriend and her fiance, which triggered a criminal investigation, according to court records.
SeattlePI.com obtained court records this week showing that Mahoney's ex-girlfriend, Siolo Thompson, filed for a court protection order against him in March 2006. Her then-fiance, Bart Keogh, a doctor at Harborview Medical Center, also said in a sworn statement that Mahoney made threats to kill him.
Both said Mahoney was jealous, verbally and physically abusive to Thompson, and had used his authority as a police officer to reach her at work. A judge declined to issue a permanent order, which would have required Mahoney to surrender his gun, but entered a less restrictive restraining order under a settlement between both sides, according to court records.
Mahoney and Thompson have a son together. After their separation in 2003, the court awarded custody to Mahoney with a visitation plan. In his statements from that case, Mahoney said Thompson, also a trained martial artist, was unstable and the one who threatened him, once warning that she would run away with their son to South America, where she is from, according to court documents.
Keogh also filed a complaint with Seattle police, which was investigated. King County prosecutors reviewed the allegations but didn't file charges in part because the woman later decided not to cooperate, saying she feared jeopardizing Mahoney's career, said Ian Goodhew, chief of staff in the Prosecutor's Office.
Prosecutors require proof the victim had a reasonable fear of the threat. Another issue arose with the fiance's call to police, in which he had at first phrased as a hypothetical "what-if" an officer had threatened to kill him, Goodhew said.
The Police Department also found no evidence of misconduct and the investigation was closed. No information from that case was presented during Mahoney's Civil Service Commission hearing.
"It was so baseless and far-fetched, even the City didn't bother to do anything with it," said Higgins, Mahoney's attorney, after Tuesday's hearing on the current case. "Unfortunately, with people in family situations, people are mad at each other and there are high emotions and the courts are brought in. But there was no basis for it and that was the conclusion of everyone who looked at it."
The prior case wasn't presented this week to the Civil Service Commission because no charges were filed, which raised questions of its relevance, Assistant City Attorney Paul Olsen said after Tuesday's hearing.
In her request for the protection order, Thompson said she started dating Mahoney in 1996 when she was 19 and taking a kickboxing class that he taught at the University of Portland. Mahoney was then an adjunct professor of philosophy at the school, according to court records.
Several Seattle police officers testified this week in support of Mahoney. Many described him as a top-notch training instructor and an "asset" to the department. Some of the same officers defended him in court against his ex-girlfriend's domestic-violence allegations three years ago.
Sgt. Rich O'Neill, president of the Seattle Police Officers Guild, criticized the investigation, saying the department failed to question other potential witnesses or follow up on possibly exonerating evidence. He said Mahoney got hardball questions, while Newstrom was tossed a few softballs. Typically, lying must be proved with evidence of intent, he said.
"When someone is bringing allegations this serious, that allegation should be tested," he said.
Mahoney said he's filed a claim with the city's Office of Civil Rights against the Police Department, alleging discrimination against him for defending his girlfriend.
Under questioning from Olsen, the city's attorney, Mahoney testified about a letter he sent in January to the state Department of Labor and Industries accusing Sgt. Little of defrauding the state workers compensation fund. It also accused Assistant Chief Nick Metz of covering up misconduct. The letter was sent after Mahoney was suspended, according to testimony.
Yet, Mahoney said he would like to return to his prior assignment and continue improving self-defense training for officers. The Civil Service Commission is expected to rule within 90 days.
_____________________________
http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/localnews/2009180826_spdappeal06m.html
